Somebody is wedged against the radiator. The chair legs keep snagging on the rug. Overhead, a single bright bulb makes the table feel like an interview. The food was lovely, and by nine o'clock everyone has drifted into the kitchen anyway. A dining room should make people want to stay put, and most of them fail at it for the same few reasons.

Choose the table for the room, then test it against the guest list

Most dining rooms go wrong at the first decision. The table gets bought for the biggest gathering of the year, then lives in the room for the other three hundred and sixty days, crowding every walkway.

Start with the floor, not the catalogue. Mark the table's footprint with masking tape or old newspaper, then add space for the chairs. I'd leave around 90 cm to a metre between the table edge and the nearest wall or sideboard, so a chair can be pulled out and a person can still squeeze behind it. If you cannot manage that on every side, the table is too big or the wrong shape.

Shape matters more than people expect. Rectangular tables suit long, narrow rooms and seat the most people. Round tables suit squarer rooms and are kinder to conversation, since nobody is stranded at the far end of a long run of guests. Oval and rounded-rectangle tops sit between the two and soften corners that catch hips and knees.

An extending table is a sensible answer if you host occasionally, provided the room copes with it fully open. Check that before you buy, not at the first dinner.

Seats you can still sit on after dessert

A beautiful chair that numbs you after forty minutes will empty a room faster than a bad menu. Sit in anything before you buy it, and sit for longer than feels polite in the showroom. Check the seat depth, the angle of the back and whether your arms rest naturally at the table edge.

Look at the height relationship between chair and table too. Legs need room to move under the tabletop without the diner feeling perched. Chairs with arms look generous, but they must slide under the table, or the seating will always sit a little away from it.

Upholstery is a practical decision as much as a stylish one. Dining chairs meet food, drink and the occasional child, so wipeable or hard-wearing finishes keep a room looking considered for longer than something delicate that everyone tiptoes around. Upholstered side chairs with a contrasting pair at the ends give the table a sense of occasion at no extra cost.

Benches tuck away and squeeze in an extra person on a busy night. They also offer no back support, so I keep them for casual, quick meals.

Colour, texture and the echo problem

Dining rooms are mostly used in the evening, so your colours will be seen under lamplight. Deep, enveloping shades look wonderful after dark and make a room feel intimate, but they need good daytime light or the room turns heavy. Paler schemes suit rooms that also host long breakfasts and lunches. If you are undecided, look at paint samples in the room at the hour you will actually be sitting down to eat, and use my guide to choosing a colour scheme for your home to test them properly.

Texture does the quiet work of making a room feel finished. A wooden table, linen at the windows, a woven or wool rug and something with a little shine, such as a mirror or glazed pottery, will make a restrained palette feel layered.

Then there is sound, which nobody mentions until they have lived with the problem. Hard floors, bare walls, glass and a wooden table make a lively echo. Lovely for a bell. Tiring for dinner, once a room full of people is talking. Curtains, upholstered seats, a generous rug and soft wall coverings or artwork all absorb it. You will never notice them working. You will notice if they are missing.

Lighting that flatters the faces round the table

The light over the table does more for the mood than anything else in the room. A single pendant or chandelier centred over the table gives focus, and a dimmer lets the room move from homework and breakfast to a late supper. Hang it so it lights the table without dazzling anyone across it. Around 75 to 90 cm above the tabletop is a sound starting point, adjusted for your ceiling height, and nobody should have to lean round it to see the person opposite.

Overhead light alone flattens a room and throws shadows across faces. Candles, a lamp on the sideboard and wall lights at a lower level soften the whole picture. I cover the full approach in my guide to how to layer lighting in a luxury home, and it applies here as much as anywhere.

Give the rest of the room a job

The table is the star and everything else supports it. A sideboard or console takes the serving dishes and glasses that would otherwise crowd the table, and hides what you would rather not see. A good-sized mirror brings light in and doubles the glow of the candles. Art hung at seated eye level rewards the people who stay for a long evening.

If the dining space is part of a kitchen-diner, the same rules hold. The table still needs room to breathe, and lighting and flooring can quietly mark it out as its own place. The kitchen layout guide shows how to keep the cook's route clear of the diners.

And resist saving the room for best. A dining room used twice a year turns into a store for boxes and an ironing board. Give it a second job, such as homework, puzzles or a laptop on a quiet afternoon, and it stays alive.

Plan backwards from nine o'clock

Picture the evening you would love and work back from the end of it. Where does the first drink happen? Who sits where? What does the room look like at nine, with the plates cleared and nobody in a hurry to move? Answer those on paper and the choice of table, chairs and lighting gets easier.

If you would like a second pair of eyes on your own room, talk through your dining room with me.